Colonel Eugene A. Carr, 6th Cavalry, Commander’s Report of the Campaign

I found the Indians retiring, though still firing, and pursued them for some distance towards their camp, when as night was falling and they were fully repulsed and the policy was not to bring on an engagement, I returned.

e-a-carrColonel and brevet Major General Eugene Asa Carr was the sixty-year-old commander of the 6th Cavalry Regiment and had held that position for a dozen years.  During the Civil War Carr had been distinguished with five brevet promotions through major general and a rare promotion to brigadier general in the U.S. Volunteers for distinguished services at the battle of Pea Ridge, action for which he was eventually awarded a Medal of Honor in 1894.  Up to the time of the Pine Ridge Campaign of 1890-1891, his regiment had served continuously for the previous fourteen years in the Department of Arizona.  Six soldiers of his regiment ultimately were awarded Medals of Honor for actions at Grass Creek on New Year’s Day, 1891, based on the recommendation of Colonel Carr.  The regiment’s deployment to Pine Ridge and associated tribulations were all the greater because the movement was a permanent change of station and involved the travel of families and personal property in addition to troopers, horses and equipage.  Carr submitted his campaign report to Brigadier General John R. Brooke toward the end of April while on leave in New York City.

New York City,
April 20th, 1891.
On leave of absence.

Assistant Adjutant General, Department of the Platte, Omaha, Nebraska.

Sir:  Circumstances have prevented my making, heretofore, a detailed report of the services of my command during the recent Sioux campaign, of which I now respectfully submit the following narrative.

On Sunday, November 23, 1890, I received at Fort Wingate, New Mexico, from Brig. Gen. A. McD. McCook, commanding the Department of Arizona, who was then at Fort Union, N.M., a dispatch stating that my regiment, the Sixth Cavalry, was relieved from duty in his department and assigned to the Department of the Platte, and to report the day and hour field officers and troops at Fort Wingate could be ready to move.  I reported that we could be ready in ten days, perhaps sooner.  We were in fact on the trains on the seventh day thereafter, December the first.  This order came like a clap of thunder out of a clear sky.

We had made our calculations and preparations for winter.  Among others the storing of our winter vegetables.  Our gardens at Fort Wingate being exceptionally good, and cultivated with great labor and care, had furnished a fine store for the benefit of the soldiers, which had to be sacrificed.

I telegraphed for further information, and, several days later, was informed that the families of officers could remain at Fort Wingate till the stations of the regiment should become known, but both they and the soldiers’ families would not stay, and, in fact, could not with any comfort.  We therefore packed all of our regimental, company, household, and other private property, in seven days.

Through want of energy at department headquarters, the commanding general being absent, no orders were given for the paymaster to come to Wingate, but we paid the command at Albuquerque while we were watering and feeding the horses and giving the men their coffee.

My regimental quartermaster was unable to obtain his receipts for the post quartermaster’s and subsistence property till all was counted over by his successor, and I was therefore deprived of his services for three weeks of the most difficult part of the campaign; my adjutant was inexperienced, though most attentive, and I was consequently obliged to attend to a great part of the staff duty myself.

There were few travel rations at Wingate, no provisions being kept on hand for such a movement, and bread had to be baked and beeves slaughtered and cooked.  Much of the beef so cooked spoiled and was wasted en-route.  Flour was also taken and exchanged for fresh bread at railroad towns.  November 28 a dispatch was received suspending the movement till further orders, but directing command to be held in readiness.  December 1, at 12:25, midnight, order was received to move at once.  In an hour the wagons were lumbering about the post taking up property, and all were at the station before the cars were ready.

The Palace Cars furnished for the horses proved unsatisfactory, in that it was impossible to water them without the water overflowing and wetting their legs and the floors of the cars.  This would freeze, making the latter slippery and involving danger of falling and rheumatism.


On the 7th I received a telegram to stop at Rapid City and encamp awaiting instructions, and on Monday, December 9, we arrived there, having started on the first from the farther border of New Mexico west of the Continental divide, and traversed the States of Colorado, Kansas and Nebraska, going east almost to Omaha; then north and west again almost to Wyoming, and stopping at the foot of the Black Hills of Dakota where I had campaigned in 1876.

I had, by frequent telegrams, kept General Brooke informed of my whereabouts and strength in case he had need of my services.  But the first orders I received were from General Ruger.  He had sent directions to Fort Meade causing Lieut. Eugene A. Ellis, 8th Cavalry, to look out a camp for me at Rapid City and to meet me at Oelrichs.

I desire here to express my thanks, and those of my regiment, to that officer for his care and attention, particularly in furnishing supplies, and in caring for the families of my officers and soldiers at Fort Meade.  Also to Dr. McGillycuddy of Rapid City for courtesies there.

Telegram from Headquarters Department of Dakota, dated December 9, received at Rapid City, informed me “It is desired that your (my) command be prepared for field service as soon as may be.”

Also states, “The first immediate duty for yourself and command, nothing intervening requiring other action, will be to see that no parties of Sioux Indians, particularly from Pine Ridge, commit depredations or roam about among the settlements along the Cheyenne River; taking in the region in particular from Battle Creek to Big Box Elder.  Captain Carr with four troops is at Oelrichs.  Captain Wells with two troops and two companies on Cheyenne six miles from Belle Fourche.  It is expected that a company of Cheyenne scouts under Lieutenant Casey may be sent you” (me).

These scouts never joined, and I was obliged to depend on guides and scouts picked up in the country, upon maps, and upon myself and my own men, for information, scouting and expressing.  My former experience in such regions was here of value.

I sent Maj. David Perry with Troops E and G, Sixth Cavalry, December 10, to the neighborhood of the mouth of Battle Creek, about forty miles distant, with orders to prevent parties of Sioux Indians from committing depredations or roaming about among the settlements along the Cheyenne River.

I now sent to Fort Meade the instruments of the Band and took the men along to perform troopers duty.

Telegram dated December 10, also from General Ruger, states:

Division Commander says, should the hostile element break up you may expect that several of the principal ones will endeavor to escape; therefore direct your troops to take such precautions as will anticipate and intercept any small bands attempting to get away; you (I) will be vigilant, and make such disposition of your (my) force as may serve to intercept any parties attempting to escape.  The part of the country as far north as Buffalo Gap the commanding officer Oelrichs will especially look after; that part from Buffalo Gap to Battle Creek Captain Wells, or whoever may be in command of troops in vicinity of Buffalo Gap, will especially look after.  The commanding officer Sixth Cavalry will especially look after country along the Cheyenne River from Battle creek to ground covered by Lieutenant Colonel Sumner’s command near Smithville, and will dispatch officer with force from his command at Rapid City to take position for duty stated.  It is not, of course, intended that the range of movement by the troops shall be confined to ground west of Cheyenne River….

Ruger, Brigadier General Commanding.

Brooke's Map from Pine Ridge 1890

(Click to enlarge) Section of “Map of the Pine Ridge & Rosebud Indian Reservations and Adjacent Territory,” prepared by the Department of the Platte Engineer Office from 1890 authorities.[2]

Pursuant to the above I sent Maj. T. C. Tupper with Troops A, I and E, Sixth Cavalry, towards the mouth of Box Elder Creek.

Thus my command in three days from arrival at Rapid City was divided into three detachments about forty miles apart.  I had been, and was, busily occupied in fitting it for the field; getting the winter clothing, tents, transportation, guides, &c., &c.

The transportation pertaining to my command in the Department of Arizona had not come with me but was ordered subsequently, and was not in the condition it would have been had it been shipped under my direction.  Some wagons had been sent from Texas, and I had to hire some which did not, of course, prove to be altogether satisfactory.  I had, however, got five troops off, and was getting the rest into tolerable shape, and was thinking of a little rest on Sunday, December 14.  The bells were ringing, and most of the command had started for church when the telegraph manager came to my tent with the dispatch which follows:

Pine Ridge, S.D.,
December 14, 1890, 9:25 a.m.

Colonel Carr, Rapid City, S.D.

The Indians in Bad Lands refuse to permit the Indians sent from here to approach their camp.  Would advise keeping your troops in as large bodies as possible.  Scouts report an intention to attack your troops this morning; the signal being to fire the grass, which has been done.  They number about 100, and will undoubtedly be recruited here.  Will have more positive information this morning.  Have advised Colonel Sanford.

Jno. R. Brooke,
Brigadier General Commanding.

I immediately sounded the General, sent orders to Tupper to join me at the mouth of Rapid Creek, and got off before noon with Troops C, D, and H, Sixth Cavalry, leaving Troop F, Capt. W. H. Carter, to finish setting up the aparejos of the pack mules and to ship to Fort Meade the remaining stuff not needed in the field.  Having been regimental quartermaster he was peculiarly adapted for that duty which he performed with dispatch, and then joined the command.  I marched on Sunday at walk, trot and gallop till dark, hearing en-route from a school teacher a rumor that a company, presumably one of Perry’s, had been massacred, and seeing to the S. E. a light of burning prairies, the stated signal for the attack.  Next morning had reveille at 4, started at daylight, and arrived at mouth of Rapid Creek soon after noon.  This was one of the most disagreeable marching days I ever experienced; very cold and bleak, with a wind so strong that I kept details of men with the wagons to hold them from blowing over.  On the way I received the following;

Pine Ridge Agency, S.D.,
December 14, 1890.

General Carr, Rapid City, S.D.  (To be forwarded by special courier if necessary.)

Can you not cover the Deadwood and Chamberlain road to east of the Cheyenne, this would prevent escape to north.  I may send Seventh Cavalry against Indians to-morrow, and want you to move in from the north if I do.  Arrange to have telegram sent after you by special courier so that an attack may be decisive if made.  I am only waiting positive information as to Two Strikes’ movements, and from the camp in Bad Lands, which I hope to get to-day.  Let me have any information you may get.

Jno. R. Brooke, Brigadier General.

I sent Troop D in advance with orders to cross the Cheyenne and cover this road.  Arriving at the mouth of Rapid Creek, Creston P.O., I found that Troop D had been unable to cross the Cheyenne on account of ice, but I soon found a crossing for them.  I had also sent ahead two soldiers with very explicit instructions to go to the mouth of Rapid Creek and then follow the Cheyenne valley up till they found Major Perry and deliver to him my orders to join.  He had reported to me that he would be eight or twelve miles above the mouth of Rapid.  These men returned without reaching Major Perry, stating that they could not find him, but being no doubt affected by the alarming rumors all through the country.  I reproached them for their want of resolution, and they subsequently preformed good military service.  These incidents indicate the state of tension of feeling all through that region and the uselessness of expecting soldiers to do express work.  I then employed a young man who was in charge of the store and post office at Creston, who delivered my orders to Major Perry and he rejoined me next day.  My regiment was frequently dispersed and concentrated as above during the campaign of six weeks, or twelve weeks counting from the starting from three posts in New Mexico, one in Colorado, to their final stations in Nebraska and Wyoming.

A report came of an Indian having been killed by watchers at Cole’s ranch about five miles up the Cheyenne.  Mrs. Cole and her daughter, just budding into womanhood, were the only females in that whole region who had not left their homes.  Miss Cole had burst into tears of anger and mortification and positively refused when urged to leave her home.  She had subsequently mounted her horse and carried a message to another ranch where the men were afraid to go.  She is fit to be the wife of a soldier and the mother of heroes.  A party of men had gathered there and were in the stable, when an Indian, afterwards identified as Dead Hand, tried to steal the horses.  He crawled into the yard and might easily have got away with three animals, but, not satisfied, tried the stable door.  He was sufficiently civilized to possess a box of matches, one of which he struck to find the latch.  This exposed him to those inside who fired and filled his head and shoulders with buck shot.  Dr. McGillycuddy recognized him as an Indian who had been baptized by Bishop Hare.  He usually bore a cross on his breast, but on this occasion he had wrapped around him several lariats, as being more useful in leading away the horses he hoped to steal.  I mention this incident as part of the narrative and not to throw any discredit upon efforts to Christianize and civilize the Indians, which have resulted in great good, and particularly with these very Indians, whom I was fighting only fourteen years previously when they were unmitigated savages.  Although another Indian attempted to, and some did, steal horses from, and commit other depredations upon, the ranches along the Cheyenne, this is the only one killed whose body was secured.  He was recognized also by the Indian wife of Mr. Farnam, who said he was her cousin, and who performed the customary ceremony of crying over the corpse.

General Miles had informed me that he understood that this Farnam was in full sympathy with the hostiles.  He had a ranch across the Cheyenne below the mouth of Rapid, and I notified him that if he staid there I would be obliged to place a guard at the ranch, but that he might return to Rapid City.  He replied that he stood on his rights as an American citizen, but afterwards came to camp to see me and compromised on remaining at the Post Office where he was under sufficient surveillance to prevent any information going from his family to the hostiles.  He said “I thought we were civilized,” meaning his Indian family, and that he and they should be trusted, and showed me a letter from his daughter who was at the school at Pine Ridge, well written and giving an account of the excitement there, and of the departure of the Indians for the Stronghold.  This Stronghold, which was now our “Objective Point,” will no doubt receive the necessary attention in the report of the Commanding General of the Department of the Platte.  It was described to me as a mesa or table land with precipitous sides, partly wooded, with several springs, accessible by one narrow wagon road and only two or three trails.  It was S.E. and opposite the mouth of Battle Creek, about twelve miles distant from the Cheyenne River.

I, of course, gathered all possible information concerning it, and studied incessantly the problem of attack.  Besides my communications from Captain Wells, Eighth Cavalry, and reports from Major Perry of my command, I was in constant communication with Colonel H. M. Day, aide to the Governor of South Dakota, and other State officers, who were doing all possible to protect and re-assure the settlers.

I was receiving orders direct from Brigadier Generals Ruger and Brooke, and Major General Miles, who had established his headquarters at Rapid City, all of which I obeyed to the best of my ability.  Their purport being to prevent, at all hazards, the passing of Sioux Indians to the north or south across a line at least seventy five miles long, the two bodies of hostiles being nearly or quite a hundred miles apart; to prevent the junction of Big Foot’s band with the others, and to capture or destroy him if encountered.  The duties imposed, although flattering to myself and my regiment, were exceedingly onerous upon nine small troops of about 50 men each, without Infantry or scouts.  But we did prevent the junction; forcing Big Foot so far to the east that the ample force at Pine Ridge Agency intervened.  Lieutenant Colonel Offley, Seventeenth Infantry, arrived at my camp December 27, with one company of his regiment and a Hotchkiss revolving cannon which had broken its pintle coming down a hill.  This was fixed with a chain obtained from a farmer who came to me for pay.  There being no appropriation applicable I believe it was considered in the hay.

Lieutenant Colonel Offley had Captain Roberts’ company, Seventeenth Infantry, which he expected to take with him up the Cheyenne, but having been notified by General Miles that I was to have a company of that regiment, I ordered him to stay with me.  Captain Carter’s troop, Sixth Cavalry, with Lieutenant Colonel Morrow, who had been left sick, had come in on 20th to 21st and with them Lieutenant Cronkhite with two Mountain Hotchkiss guns.  The horses with these guns were unshod, their feet were tender, and the first request I received was for the cavalry blacksmith to shoe them.  They were also without pack saddles or mules which I was obliged to provide as well as possible from the transportation of the troops.

General Brooke had formulated a plan for the attack of the Stronghold which he sent to me, but the Indians at Pine Ridge Agency wanted to make another effort to induce the hostiles to come in, and it was suspended.  Meantime Sitting Bull was killed and some of his followers joined Big Foot’s band of Cherry Creek, north of Belle Fourche.

I was ordered December 15 from Saint Paul to look out both ways, and prevent a junction between the bands, and to communicate with Lieut. Col. E. V. Sumner, Eighth Cavalry, who had three troops, two companies and scouts below Smithville on the Cheyenne near the mouth of Belle Fourche.  I was authorized by General Brooke to send any necessary orders to Captain Wells at Oelrichs and the mouth of Battle Creek, and by General Miles to give any orders to Lieutenant Colonel Sumner; but I saw nothing to do unless to move them from their stations, which was not contemplated by the Generals.

I sent, December 20, a battalion under Major Emil Adam, Sixth Cavalry, to the eastward to go down to White River to the neighborhood of the mouth of “Bear in Lodge” Creek, about forty miles distant, to protect the settlers and intercept Indians going north or south.  The final effect of this movement, together with my scout to the Pinnacle and Bull Creek, was to throw Big Foot’s band so far east that they did not form junction with the others.

It appears that Lieutenant Colonel Sumner reported that he had captured Big Foot; at least orders were sent to him through me to bring him to the railroad, to Fort Meade, or to my camp.  He had not, however, reduced him to possession, and when he started to do so the bird had flown.  He sent me the following which I received December 24th after 10 a.m.

Camp on Cheyenne River,
Near Big Foot’s village, S.D.
Time 7 p.m. Dec. 23, ‘90

Colonel E. A. Carr, Rapid City, S.D.

Big Foot did not come into my camp to-day as promised and I started for him this afternoon.  His lookouts of course let him know that I was on the road.  He sent me word by messenger that he would go to Fort Bennett to-morrow with all his people, but when I approached his village I found it vacant, and my scouts have informed me that he has gone up Deep Fork Trail, due south, that he will probably pass Mexican Ed’s and head of Bull Creek near the Bad Lands.  If you can move out to-morrow morning (a force) you will doubtless intercept him.  They had yesterday a hundred fighting men, and about three hundred altogether including women and children.  They started from here in very light order, no wagons, all had ponies and will travel very fast.  For fear they may return here I will stay here to-night, scout up Deep Creek to-morrow, and if I hear nothing will start for Smithville and go out Bull Creek towards Bad Lands.  Dispatches from General Miles relative to Indians coming from the north and west of me in considerable numbers prevent my following the trail and getting out of reach.  I hope you will get this in time and you will head them off.

E. V. Sumner,
Lieut. Col. 8th Cavalry, Commanding Camp.

Received 10 a.m. Dec. 24, 1890.

(1st Endorsement.)

Headquarters Sixth Cavalry,
In the Field, Camp mouth of Rapid Creek, S.D.
December 24, 1890.

Respectfully forwarded to General Miles.  I am starting with all troops here to cut the trail.  One troop out patrolling and four troops go with me.

E. A. Carr, Colonel Sixth Cavalry, Commanding.

I feared that Big Foot had already passed, but sounded “boots and saddles” at once, and with the four troops in camp and the two Hotchkiss guns, was off in half an hour without waiting to pack provisions, blankets or tents.

The nearest trail or road by which he could travel was twelve miles east of me, the next twenty miles.  My best guide was an old man named Americus Thompson, who lived there, but was half dazed and left me that night without leave.

However I held towards the east and arrived at the first road (which is the old Fur Company’s road from Laramie to Pierre) at 12:30.  There were no signs of the passage of such a band as that of Big Foot, and I continued on to the other road, being obliged to make some detours in the Bad Lands which I there struck for the first time.  They are nothing in comparison with the rocky and inhospitable regions of Arizona and New Mexico, nor so difficult as the mountains of the Big Horn or deserts of Western Texas and the Indian Territory, in all of which I have served.  They consist of a deposit of a soft sediment, which after the secession of the bodies of water, has been washed by ages of rain fall into ravines and gulches, leaving fantastic bluffs and so called walls which offer some, but not great, impediment to travel.  They are mostly covered with grass, though bare in places, and I found water frequently, though it is more or less alkaline.

I reached the second road before dark and found that Big Foot had not passed there.  Leaving a hidden picket near this road I retired a mile or two to a valley which I had crossed, one of the heads of Sage Creek, and went into camp, that is, unsaddled and picketed the horses, and prepared to take what rest was possible, sending also a picket back to the other road where there was a house.  During the night the first picket reported signal flashes, which on investigation proved to be the opening and closing of the door of the house where the second picket had a fire.  Two troops which had been on detached service joined during the night with four guides, one of which I sent to the south east through Sage Creek Gap, with information and orders to Major Adam on White River.  I also sent back for provisions and for ammunition for the Hotchkisses.

The day had been cold and raw and the night was bitter.  Some men and officers had brought blankets; some had provisions and some had not.  By dividing all had something to eat, and water was obtained by melting the ice which had frozen to the bottom of most of the water holes.  Where there was any left it looked like pea soup and tasted like a dose of salts.  We cut holes in the ice but the horses would not drink the water, even when they could be induced to approach them.  Next day, however, they were glad to get any water, some of them slipped down on the ice and drank while lying by the holes.

We spent our Christmas eve standing, sitting and lying around the fires, sleeping from time to time till wakened by the cold.

I had sent no orders to the Artillery when sounding “boots and saddles.”  It had no pack mules for carrying the guns or ammunition, but Lieut. Cronkhite hitched up and came along all the same, with only seven rounds.  His shaft connections had broken, nuts had come off, etc., but he had rawhided them up and followed along the trail chosen only for Cavalry.

During the night I had learned from Mr. Reed, who had come along as a volunteer guide and was the only man who knew the country properly, that these two trails came together near Bull Creek, ten miles to the northward and towards Big Foot’s country.  I therefore, in the morning, divided my command into two parts, sending one under Lieutenant Colonel Morrow, along the western trail, while I took the eastern till we joined at Bull Creek.

There was a point of the wall still further east called the Pinnacle, from which I was told the country could be viewed for thirty miles further, to which I sent two officers with a small party, but they could see no Indians.

Arriving at Bull Creek at noon I examined the crossing and the valley above and below, there were no signs of Indians and no water.  This was less than forty miles from where Deep Creek enters the Cheyenne, and which point, according Sumner, Big Foot had left three days previously, he therefore could not be coming toward me, and I started for my camp, arriving some time after dark, and having traveled over seventy miles since ten 0’clock of the day previous, and myself and command spending Christmas differently from most of our friends.

I tried to write a report but could not keep awake and went to bed, and had my first six hours unbroken sleep since the night of November 22.  The General commanding did not know where I was and sent me no dispatches that night.

About this time I established a heliograph line to Rapid City with only one intermediate station, but there was so little sunshine that but few messages passed over it and it resulted in the loss for a considerable period of the service of 1st Lieutenant Dravo, and about a dozen soldiers which included nearly all the expert signalers, as I was ordered to leave the party with the heliograph line on Rapid City.

The whereabouts of Big Foot’s band was (December 26 to 28) still unknown.  Sumner’s scouts were totally unreliable, but I heard reports of Big Foot’s passing southward to the east of Mexican Ed’s which is a ranch on one of the heads of Bad River near where the roads from Laramie, Deadwood and Rapid City join going to Pierre.  That “Deadwood and Chamberlain Road” so prominent on the maps, and so frequently mentioned in the dispatches, it is not a travelled road at all but a line which was reconnoitered for a railroad which was never built.  It was most embarrassing to receive orders to cover that road and have the troops find it necessary to go many miles around to get a point near it.  The guides I had knew little or nothing of it, and were bewildered when I talked to them about covering it.

Major Adam in order to reach the point on White River called “Bear in Lodge” or “Bear runs under the lodge” had gone a little east of south on the Valentine or Porcupine road, then southeast down to Cottonwood, and then northeast down White River, making the distance about twice what it would be in a straight line.  All other roads east of Cheyenne were similarly obscure and the guides being cowmen and boys with little use for wagons, had not noticed them much and knew but little about them.

During this time period, 26th to 28th, I received many dispatches, their purport being to “look out for Big Foot going south, prevent his junction with the others, and to intercept him if possible,” also “to prevent escapes to the north of hostiles in bad lands.”

I kept troops out daily scouting up and down the Cheyenne and to the eastward and south eastward.  Sumner and Merriam had orders to follow Big Foot closely and join me, but those orders appeared, from such copies and reports as I saw, and the results, to have been partly ignored, and partly countermanded.

Finally at 10:40, p.m. December 28, I received information that Major Whitside had captured Big Foot, and notification that I was to move to White River, and orders came to 4:20, a.m., as follows:

Headquarters Division of the Missouri,
Rapid City, S.D., December 28th 1890,
(Rec’d. 4:20, a.m., 29)

Col. E. A. Carr, Commanding Mouth of Rapid Creek, S.D.

Sir:  The Division Commander directs that you leave two troops to continue the examination of the bad lands for any Indians that may be hiding, or arms cached, and move with the balance of your command tomorrow morning towards White River, to arrive on that river between mouth of Porcupine and Wounded Knee Creeks not later than the evening of Tuesday the 30th instant.

Sending word to the Division Commander at Daly’s Ranch to-morrow night, where your headquarters will be at that time, and on the night of the 30th make your Headquarters at the mouth of Wounded Knee.

Take if possible all your stores, if you can find transportation, and what cannot be transported leave under a small guard to be “returned to Rapid City.”

The Division Commander will be at Daly’s ranch tomorrow night and will camp on White River at crossing of Flour road next night.  Send report to last named place, of your movements and position.

Direct the two troops left in the Bad Lands after completing of their work to rejoin your command.

      I have the honor to be, Very respectfully, Your obedient servant,

Marion P. Maus,
1st Lieut. 1st Infantry, Aide-de-Camp.

The transportation was insufficient and I had to leave a lot of grain with a guard under Lieutenant Nickerson, 17th Infantry, but I got off pretty early, and, marching till long after dark, camped at the mouth of Cottonwood Creek, passing Major Adam’s battalion which was at Cottonwood Springs.  This was my first camp on the Pine Ridge Indian Reservation, and was at the house of a squaw man or half breed who had hay and fuel, a cooking and heating stove, bureau, mirror, tables, chairs, bedstead and a melodeon.  I was struck with the constant evidence of improvement and comfort of the Indians from here on, and, particularly along Wounded Knee Creek, which is a most beautiful stream of clear good water with frequent springs along its banks.  It has the peculiarity of rising in night and falling during the day several feet, so that my men complained the first night that there was no water.  It was then quite difficult to water stock or even to dip up water on account of its shallowness and of the ice.

I had campaigned in that region fourteen years previously when there was no sign of civilization.  Now there were wire fences, mowing machines, horse rakes, plows, barrows, wagons, stables, sewing machines, washing machines, etc.

I found all the hay I required for 800 animals, for over two weeks, besides plenty of beeves, a milch cow and several broken horses.  There was a church and school-house in the valley, (The latter had been burned) but there were fifteen or twenty houses in sight of it.  The houses and doors, windows, stoves and furniture provided by the United States.  All were abandoned and had been more or less plundered.

December 29, I received information of the 7th Cavalry affair at Wounded Knee, both from General Miles and Major Henry.  I marched up White River and encamped as ordered, at mouth of Wounded Knee, being joined en-route by Major Adam, and passing where Major Henry’s fires were still burning.

Major Emil Adam, Sixth Cavalry, is entitled to great credit for his management during the detached service with his battalion from December 20, to 30, which contributed materially to prevent the junction of Big Foot’s Band with the other hostiles.

I was informed that Major Henry, who had four troops Ninth Cavalry, intended to encamp twelve miles up Wounded Knee Creek, and to open communication with him.  I detailed Sergeant McTague, with six men on the fastest horses.  He started about an hour by sun and I did not hear of him again for several days.  Two Indian Scouts came in with dispatches from Pine Ridge who said that they had met Indians on the road, and had been obliged to make long detours.  When Sergeant McTague returned, he reported that he had travelled up the valley more than twelve miles without finding Major Henry’s camp, but continued on, as he was satisfied that he could perceive the tracks of his horses and wagons, though it was after dark; that during the night he saw two parties of Indians around fires, and charged them and they scattered in the brush.

He went on to Pine Ridge, arriving in the forenoon after Major Henry whose wagons had been attacked by Indians.

Sergeant McTague reported to General Brooke, who kept him for a day and then allowed him to return with dispatches.  His was the only small party which traversed the Wounded Knee road.  This gallant and faithful sergeant was within a few months of his retirement for thirty years of faithful service, but has since died of pneumonia contracted in the bitter weather since the close of the campaign.

On the afternoon of January 1, 1891, my Saddler Sergeant McGrath who was in charge of the men at my regimental headquarters told me that he heard firing up White River.  Captain Kerr’s troop K, was in that direction and I ordered Major Tupper to saddle up the other two troops of his battalion, to which Kerr belonged, and re-enforce him.  I then ordered two troops of Major Adam’s battalion, A, and H, to saddle, and, upon receiving a message from Captain Kerr by two of his men, who were greatly excited, I proceeded with the latter two troops at full speed to the scene of action, which was not far from the mouth of Grass Creek, where a road crosses White River towards their stronghold.

I found the Indians retiring, though still firing, and pursued them for some distance towards their camp, when as night was falling and they were fully repulsed and the policy was not to bring on an engagement, I returned.  They had probably come out with the intention to break through our line to their old stronghold on the mesa of the Bad Lands, but were defeated and driven back, and made no other serious attempt.

I commend Major Tullius C. Tupper, Sixth Cavalry, for activity, energy and bravery; Captain John B. Kerr, Sixth Cavalry, for coolness, ability and bravery; Captain William H. Carter, Sixth Cavalry, and 1st Lieutenant George H. Sands for the same.  See my letter of February 2, 1891, recommending these officers for brevets.  Lieutenant Sands is also entitled to credit for his performance of quartermaster’s duty while outfitting at Rapid City and at the mouth of Rapid Creek December 8, to 25, 1890.

I have forwarded recommendations for medals of honor for Captain J. B. Kerr, 1st Lieut. B. H. Cheever, Sergeant Myers, Troop K, and Corporal Cornelius C. Smith, Troop K, and for honorable mention of 1st Lieutenant B. H. Cheever and the fourteen men of his platoon.  Corporal Keiser, Troop — who is a medalist for carbine sharpshooting, was with my headquarters party and put in some accurate shots.  He showed coolness and bravery and should have a medal.

I had previously an understanding with him and the trumpeter Van Kelst of Troop K, because of treachery while I might be negotiating with Indians, I was to order Van Kelst in French to sound “Commence firing” so that they would not understand till they heard the signal, and Corporal Keiser was to kill the Chief instantly.

The number of Indians was variously estimated from fifty to a hundred and fifty.  Several were seen to fall, three were seen dragging off the body of one and one body was secured also three saddle ponies.  We lost one horse killed and one wounded, for the next two weeks we were actively engaged in scouting against the hostile Sioux, whose camp was on or near White Clay Creek about twelve miles from mine, the object being to prevent them from going north or east and to constantly press them toward the agency.  We saw some of them nearly every day and satisfied them that there was an efficient cordon around them.

General Brooke visited my camp January 3, and stayed over night His Headquarters was near the mouth of White Clay.

My line was from the haystacks below mouth of White Clay, on White River, to Whitney’s camp on head of Wounded Knee, about forty miles to guard with about 500 men.  I still had Captain Cyrus S. Roberts, Company I, Seventeenth Infantry, which was most useful and I am greatly indebted to him for assiduous and cheerful attention to duty.

The two little Hotchkiss guns might be useful in case of a battle, but could not help in scouting.  The Cheyenne Scouts which finally arrived were newly enlisted and undisciplined.  They were inclined to loot the abandoned cabins, to pick up ponies, kill cattle and otherwise to act according to their own sweet will.

On the 12th of January, while scouting on Grass Creek toward the hostiles who were moving their camp up White Clay, while our camp was also moving up Wounded Knee, the interpreter came from the right and reported that the Cheyennes said “Indians are fighting soldiers in that direction” pointing to the southwest, which was where the troops with General Brooke were expected to be following the hostiles up White Clay.  I was trying to find a place to water where Grass Creek was not frozen, but went at full speed in the direction indicated.  I had Perry’s battalion with me and sent word to Tupper and Adam saw me galloping from seven miles off, and they all hastened to join me, but when we reached the Cheyennes, who had continued scouting to the right, they said they had sent no such message.  Then I told him (interpreter) to tell them to guide me to the camp on Wounded Knee, and he pretended to do so, but they soon disappeared and I was obliged to guide myself by taking the direction.  It was a most disagreeable, bleak, cold and sleety day and there were many trails which crooked and turned in the broken Bad Lands, making it hard to keep the points of compass.  We were thoroughly chilled when we reached camp about dark, but Roberts had made a most judicious selection, had all the tents pitched, fuel ready, etc., and we were soon comfortable.

On the 14th of January I received order to move a battalion to the beef corral on Wolf Creek, near Pine Ridge Agency.  I had Reveille at 4 o’clock, but it was so stormy and dark that we could not see the roads till 7:15 and then the guides took the wrong one, which I corrected.  After a most bleak and disagreeable march we reached the beef corral, designated, where we found Captain Whitney, 8th Infantry, who had just arrived, and went into camp with us.

The Indians were then in sight streaming along up White Clay beyond the agency.  My two other battalions arrived next day.  My camp was along the north side of Wolf Creek on high ground sloping to the southwest, facing the Indian village, which was about three miles distant.

The Indians gradually made up their minds to a complete surrender and commenced to give up their arms, and on the 23rd of January forces were assembled for the grand review of January 24, at which I commanded the Cavalry Brigade of about 1,500 men, and on the 26th took advantage of my leave of absence.

My regimental headquarters and six troops were assigned to Fort Niobrara, Neb., with orders to move when the last of the Brules had started for their homes.  The other three troops were assigned to Fort McKinney, Wyo.  Both, as I have since learned, suffered greatly from blizzards on their marches, and upon arrival found their new posts not so good as Fort Wingate or Stanton.

In writing this report I have been obliged to rely to a considerable extent upon my memory, and may hereafter wish to supply omissions or make corrections.

I desire here to express my obligations to my regimental staff officers, 1st Lieutenant Frederick G. Hodgson, Adjutant and John M. Stotsenburg, Quartermaster.

Lieutenant Hodgson, although new to the difficult and onerous duties, brought great intelligence, assiduous attention, patience and good temper to their performances.  He was always ready, prompt and cheerful.

General Eugene A. Carr

Lieutenant Stotsenburg, a most accomplished staff officer, established soon after he joined, order and system which insured the obtaining of abundant supplies, both of quartermasters and subsistence stores.

They were both on the field during the fight of January 1, 1891 and showed coolness and bravery.

I am, Sir, Very respectfully, Your obedient servant,

Eugene A. Carr, Colonel 6th Cavalry.[4]


[1] Adjutant General’s Office, Official Army Register for March 1891, (Washington: Adjutant General’s Office, 1891), 69, 274 and 296.
[2] William F. Kelley, Pine Ridge 1890: An Eye Witness Account of the Events Surrounding the Fighting at Wounded Knee, edited and compiled by Alexander Kelley & Pierre Bovis (San Francisco: Pierre Bovis, 1971), fold out map attached to back of book.
[3] Photograph of General Eugene A. Carr from USMA AOG, Forty-second Annual Reunion of the Association of Graduates of the United States Military Academy at West Point, New York, June 12th, 1911, (Saginaw: Seeman & Peters, Inc., 1911), 99.
[4] John R. Brooke, Sioux Campaign 1890-91, vols. 1 and 2 (Philadelphia: Historical Society of Pennsylvania, 1919), 1054-1067. These documents were typed and certified as true copies by 1st Lieut. James T. Dean who served as aide-de-camp to General Brooke from February 1893 to May 1895. These original certified copies appear to have been bound into two volumes and an index likely by Lieut. Dean during that same time frame. A label in the front of each volume indicates that they were presented by General Brooke to the Historical Society of Pennsylvania on 21 May 1919. A select few of these documents–145 of over 1,080 pages–are also available online from the Historical Society of Pennsylvania under the title, “Correspondence, Sioux Campaign (vol. 2),” ( accessed 8 Sep 2015.  By the fall of 1891, Brigadier General Brooke was no longer the commander of the Department of the Platte, and thus, did not submit an annual report that included his previous department’s actions during the campaign.  Had he done so, his report almost certainly would have included Colonel Carr’s report.

Citation for this article: Samuel L. Russell, “Colonel Eugene A. Carr, 6th Cavalry, Commander’s Report of the Campaign” Army at Wounded Knee ( posted 4 Oct 2015, accessed date __________.

Posted in Officers, Official Reports | Tagged , , , , , , , | 4 Comments

G Troop, 7th Cavalry Regiment Muster Roll

Muster Roll of Captain Winfield S. Edgerly’s Troop G of the Seventh Regiment of Cavalry, Army of the United States, (Colonel James W. Forsyth,) from the 31st day of October, 1890 to the 31st day of December, 1890. [Names in bold are believed to have been present at the battle of Wounded Knee.  Those annotated with § were killed in action or died of wounds, and those annotated with ¥ were awarded the Medal of Honor or the Certificate of Merit.]

Captain Edgerly, Winfield S.: Commanding Troop.

First Lieutenant Brewer, Edwin P.: With Troop.

Second Lieutenant Bell, James F.: Absent with leave since Nov. 21st, 1890 per Special Order #267 Adjutant General’s Office 1890.

¥ First Sergeant Toy, Frederick E.: Enlisted on October 16, 1888 at Fort Riley, Kansas, by Lt. McCormick.  Adjutant General’s Office–granted a Medal of Honor.

Sergeant Hennessee, Emanuel: Enlisted on October 1, 1888 at Fort Riley, Kansas, by Lt. McCormick. [Recognized in General Order No. 100.]

Sergeant Sharp, William: Enlisted on February 2, 1887 at Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, by Lt. Scott.

Sergeant Casey, Francis B.: Enlisted on December 18, 1886 at New York, New York, by Capt. Jackson.

Sergeant Rennick, William: Enlisted on November 4, 1887 at Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, by Lt. Scott.  On furlough for (3) three months from Nov. 4th, ‘90 to Feb. 3rd, ‘91 under provisions of paragraph 3 General Order #80 signed ‘90, Adjutant General’s Office.  Due soldier pay from June 1 to June 30th, ‘90.

Sergeant Rathgeber, George H.: Enlisted on January 25, 1887 at Jersey City, New Jersey, by Capt. Vroom.  Joined by transfer from Troop “L” 7th Cav., per Order No. 86 Headquarters, 7th Cav., Camp at Pine Ridge Agency, S. D., December 1, 1890.

Corporal Kopp, Adolph: Enlisted on September 6, 1888 at Cincinnati, Ohio, by Lt. Hunter.

Corporal Steckel, William L.: Enlisted on September 4, 1888 at Cleveland, Ohio, by Capt. Kellogg.

Corporal Baker, Frederick: Enlisted on April 28, 1887 at New York, New York, by Lt. Wheeler.

Corporal Devereaux, Eugene B.: Enlisted on October 12, 1888 at Detroit, Michigan, by Capt. Loud.

Trumpeter Shelman, Henry: Enlisted on March 30, 1886 at Fort Snelling, Minnesota, by Lt. Wilson.

Trumpeter Timmerman, William: Enlisted on November 14, 1887 at Milwaukee, Wisconsin, by Capt. Drum.

Farrier O’Connor, James W.: Enlisted on December 22, 1886 at Detroit, Michigan, by Capt. Loud.

Blacksmith Huston, Edward: Enlisted on July 6, 1888 at Washington, District of Columbia, by Capt. Scott.

Saddler Morten, Edward: Enlisted on July 7, 1887 at Fort Leavenworth, Kansas, by Lt. Paddock.

Wagoner Fadler, Adam: Enlisted on September 4, 1889 at New York, New York, by Lt. Carter.

Private Allen, Clarence H.: Enlisted on April 8, 1889 at Cincinnati, Ohio, by Capt. Ropes.

Private Beyer, August: Enlisted on September 11, 1887 at Springfield, Massachusetts, by Capt. Ropes.

Private Blauser, Peter H.: Enlisted on August 30, 1890 at Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, by Capt. Tisdell.  Joined Troop at Pine Ridge Agency, S. D., Dec. 6th, 1890. Assigned to troop per Order #88 Headquarters 7th Cav. In the field to date from Nov. 28th, ‘90. Due U.S. Laundry forty one (41) cents. Retained $4.00 per month until 29 Aug., ‘91.

Private Bogle, Thomas T.: Enlisted on August 15, 1888 at Springfield, Massachusetts, by Capt. Ropes.  On detached service with Band 7th Cav., at Ft Riley, Ks. per Order No. 62, Headquarters 7th Cav., Ft Riley, Ks., August 19th, 1890.

Private Bower, George: Enlisted on August 22, 1890 at Fort Riley, Kansas, by Lt. McCormick.  Retained $4.00 per month until 21 Aug., ‘91.

Private Burns, Owen: Enlisted on April 11, 1890 at Providence, Rhode Island, by Capt. Thompson.

Private Campbell, William: Enlisted on August 25, 1888 at Springfield, Massachusetts, by Capt. Ropes.

Private Carlson, Charles: Enlisted on October 11, 1888 at Denver, Colorado, by Lt. Borden.  Absent sick in Post Hospital at Fort Riley, Kansas, since Nov. 24th, 1890, disease unknown.

Private Carr, Denis: Enlisted on March 29, 1890 at Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, by Capt. Dodd.  Sentenced to forfeit to the U.S. one (1) dollar of his pay per Field Order #11, Pine Ridge Agency, S. D., Dec. 18th, 1890.

Private Cloud, John W.: Enlisted on January 4, 1890 at Columbus Barracks, Ohio, by Lt. Williams.

Private Croslon, William: Enlisted on November 9, 1887 at Boston, Massachusetts, by Capt. Miller.  On furlough since Nov. 11th, ‘90 under provisions of paragraph 3, General Order  80, signed ‘90, Adjutant General’s Office.

Private Chamberlain, Guy: Enlisted on July 22, 1887 at New York, New York, by Capt. Jackson.

Private Dougherty, Edward: Enlisted on April 15, 1890 at Cincinnati, Ohio, by Capt. Haines.

Private DuBois, Lynes R.: Enlisted on June 5, 1890 at New York, New York, by Capt. Wagner.

Private Edwards, Edward: Enlisted on May 1, 1889 at Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, by Lt. Dodd.

Private Fitzenreuter, Henry A.: Enlisted on March 20, 1889 at Detroit, Michigan, by Capt. Kennedy.

Private Hadden, John: Enlisted on December 21, 1888 at Cleveland, Ohio, by Capt. Kellogg.

¥ Private Hamilton, Matthew H.: Enlisted on July 6, 1888 at New York, New York, by Lt. Wheeler.  Adjutant General’s Office–granted a Medal of Honor.

Private Henderson, John J.: Enlisted on August 22, 1890 at Fort Riley, Kansas, by Lt. McCormick.

Private Jones, Herman B.: Enlisted on August 22, 1890 at Fort Riley, Kansas, by Lt. McCormick.

Private Jones, Henry: Enlisted on April 4, 1887 at New York, New York, by Capt. Jackson.

Private Kaiser, Frederick: Enlisted on February 6, 1889 at Fort Riley, Kansas, by Lt. McCormick.  On extra duty as Clerk in the Subsistence Department, Headquarters Department of the Platte in the Field per Field Order #9, Camp at Pine Ridge Agency, S. D., Dec. 14th, 1890.

Private Kelley, John: Enlisted on August 2, 1888 at New York, New York, by Capt. Jackson.  On Special duty as Troop Cook since Nov. 24th, 1890.

Private Kenney, Nicholas: Enlisted on December 31, 1887 at Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, by Lt. Scott.

Private Kirwan, Michael: Enlisted on November 15, 1888 at Newark, New Jersey, by Lt. Carter.

Private Kuhns, Daniel M.: Enlisted on January 8, 1886 at Jefferson Barracks, Missouri, by Lt. Mann.  Sentenced to forfeit to the U.S. three (3) dollars of his pay per field orders No. 10, Camp at Pine Ridge Agency, S.D., Dec.15th, 1890.

Private Liddy, Patrick: Enlisted on January 29, 1887 at New York, New York, by Capt. Jackson.

Private Mahoney, Frank: Enlisted on June 4, 1888 at Fort Riley, Kansas, by Lt. McCormick. [Recognized in General Order No. 100.]

Private Mahoney, George: Enlisted on October 13, 1888 at Fort Riley, Kansas, by Lt. McCormick.  In confinement since Dec. 3rd, 1890 awaiting trial by General Court Martial.

Private Mayer, John H.: Enlisted on August 6, 1888 at New York, New York, by Lt. Wheeler.  On Detached Service at Ft. Riley, Ks., since Dec. 24, 1890 per verbal order Regimental Commander.

Private Marsters, James F.: Enlisted on February 12, 1887 at Jefferson Barracks, Missouri, by Lt. Fountain.

Private Meil, John W.: Enlisted on April 16, 1889 at Cincinnati, Ohio, by Capt. Ropes. [Killed on 26 January 1891 at Irving, Kansas, in train wreck on return trip from the Pine Ridge Campaign.]

Private Moore, William B.: Enlisted on March 11, 1889 at Fort Riley, Kansas, by Lt. McCormick.  On detached service at Ft. Riley, Ks., per verbal order Regimental Commander, Dec. 24, 1890.

Private O’Brien, James R.: Enlisted on January 6, 1888 at Springfield, Massachusetts, by Capt. Ropes.

Private Palmer, Granville E.: Enlisted on December 13, 1889 at Fort Logan, Colorado, by Lt. Johnson.

Private Radenmacher, Charles: Enlisted on February 23, 1887 at Baltimore, Maryland, by Capt. Overton.

Private Reardon, Michael: Enlisted on February 15, 1888 at Jefferson Barracks, Missouri., by Lt. Fountain.

Private Ridenour, Charles: Enlisted on November 10, 1887 at Cincinnati, Ohio, by Lt. Hunter.  On furlough since Nov. 11th, ‘90 under provisions of paragraph 3, General Order  80, signed ‘90, Adjutant General’s Office.

Private Ross, Patrick: Enlisted on September 23, 1890 at Boston, Massachusetts, by Capt. Kendall.  Joined Troop at Pine Ridge Agency, S. D., Dec. 6th, 1890. Assigned to troop per Order #88 Headquarters 7th Cav., in the field to date Nov. 28th, ‘90. Due U.S. Laundry fifty one (51) cents. Retained $4.00 per month until 21 Sep., ‘91.

Private Stiles, Wilbur: Enlisted on July 1, 1887 at Fort Meade, Dakota Territory, by Lt. Hare.

Private Spaney, Paul L.: Enlisted on October 26, 1888 at Denver, Colorado, by Lt. Borden.

Private Shields, James: Enlisted on August 20, 1888 at Chicago, Illinois, by Capt. Godwin.

Private Small, William J.: Enlisted on July 9, 1889 at Baltimore, Maryland, by Capt. Huggins.

Private unknown.

Private unknown.

Private unknown.


Private unknown.

Private unknown.


Sergeant unknown.

Killed in Action

§ Private Francischetti, Dominick: Enlisted on September 9, 1889 at Chicago, Illinois, by Capt. Nowlan.  Killed in action Dec. 30, 1890, 6 miles north of Pine Ridge Agency, S.D.

Captain W. S. Edgerly's Muster Roll Recapitulation for G Troop, 7th Cavalry

(Click to enlarge) The Recapitulation and Record of Events Page of G Troop, 7th Cavalry Regiment’s Muster Roll of December, 1891.

Record of Events Which May Be Necessary or Useful for Future Reference at the War Department, or for Present Information.

Since date of last muster the Troop performed the regular Garrison duties at Ft. Riley, Kans. to Nov. 23rd, 1890.
In the field since November 24th, 1890. Left Ft. Riley, Ks., by Rail November 24th, 1890. Arrived at Rushville, Neb., Nov 26th, ‘90. Marched overland from Rushville, Neb., Nov. 26th to Camp at Water holes, Neb., distance marched 12 miles. Marched from Camp at Water holes, Neb., to Pine Ridge Agency, S.D., Nov. 27th, ‘90, distance marched 16 miles. In Camp at Pine Ridge Agency, S. D., from Nov. 27th, ‘90 to Dec. 28th, ‘90, performing regular camp duties. Marched from Pine Ridge Agency, S. D., to Wounded Knee Creek, S. D., Dec. 28th, ‘90, distance 17 miles. Participated in disarming and exterminating the Sioux Indians under Chief Big Foot. 2 horses killed and one wounded. Dec. 29th, ‘90, marched from Wounded Knee Creek to Pine Ridge Agency, S.D., distance 17 miles. Dec. 30th, 1890, participated in the engagement with Hostile Sioux Indians under Chief “Two Strike” six miles north of Pine Ridge Agency, S.D. Private Francischetti killed in action. 1 Horse wounded.
Dec. 31, ‘90, in Camp at Pine Ridge Agency, S. D.

Source: Adjutant General’s Officer, “7th Cavalry, Troop G, Jan. 1885 – Dec. 1897,” Muster Rolls of Regular Army Organizations, 1784 –  Oct. 31, 1912, Record Group 94, (Washington: National Archives Record Administration).  The original G Troop Muster Roll at the National Archives was disassembled at some point and put back together in incorrect order, and at least one page is missing.  The page annotating the names of the last three privates assigned and the transfers, discharges, and casualties according to the numbers reported in the Recapitulation section are missing as is at least one page of remarks. The information regarding Private Franceschetti was obtained from his military enlistment record, and the incorrect spelling of his last name is based on how Captain Edgerly spelled Franceschetti’s name in the Record of Events section.

Citation for this article: Samuel L. Russell, “G Troop, 7th Cavalry Regiment Muster Roll,” Army at Wounded Knee (, posted 15 Aug 2015, accessed _______.

Posted in Muster Rolls | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | 1 Comment

First Lieutenant Horatio Gates Sickel, Commander, E Troop, 7th Cavalry

…in remaining with a detachment of Troop “E”, 7th Cavalry, in a dangerous and difficult position in order to protect against possible mutilation the bodies of soldiers of his command already killed by the Indians….
–Colonel James W. Forsyth

Lieut. Horatio G. Sickel - Fighting 7th Officers - J. C. H. Grabill - colorized by Amy Gigliotti

First Lieutenant Horatio G. Sickel, Jr., E Troop, 7th Cavalry, at Pine Ridge Agency, 16 January 1891. Cropped from John C. H. Grabill’s photograph, “The Fighting 7th Officers.” Colorized by Amy Gigliotti.

Two weeks short of his thirty-seventh birthday, Horatio G. Sickel, Jr., was commanding E Troop during the Pine Ridge Campaign while Captain Charles S. Ilsley was commanding the 2nd Battalion.  Lieutenant Sickel had served in E Troop for eight years and had been with the regiment since being transferred to it following the battle along the Little Bighorn River just a couple of weeks after graduating from the United States Military Academy in 1876. The troop’s second lieutenant was Sedgwick Rice, a civilian appointee that had been with the unit since transferring to the 7th Cavalry four years earlier.  Lieutenant Sickel’s senior non-commissioned officer was First Sergeant Charles M. Clark, a veteran enlisted man with over twelve years in the saddle with the regiment and at least one prior enlistment with the 6th Infantry.  E Troop had its full compliment of officers, fourteen of its fifteen non-commissioned officers, and forty-three of its forty-five privates at Wounded Knee, twelve of which were recently assigned from the recruiting depot at Jefferson Barracks, comprising twenty-eight percent of the troop’s junior enlisted soldiers.[1]

During the fighting on Wounded Knee, E Troop suffered two men killed and one wounded and lost one horse as well. Due to the troop’s operations in the field through the middle of January, Lieutenant Sickel did not testify at the investigation of Wounded Knee.  An article in Philadelphia’s The Times, which ran on 9 February 1891, detailed some of the action to which E Troop faced and the measures Lieutenant Sickel took to avoid the unnecessary killing of two non-combatants, measures that ultimately failed to save the Lakota women from their own self-destruction.

One of the results of the fight struck me as being peculiarly horrible. The battle was about over–only an occasional shot being fired away in the distance–when two women, one old, the other young–appeared on the field from some place of concealment and began looking at the bodies of the dead of their race. They would have been shot had it not been for the interference of an officer–Lieutenant Sickles [sic]. As rapidly as possible they moved from corpse to corpse (the wounded were but few) and when near the prostrate line of waiting soldiers they found those whom they sought–their husbands. Low wails of anguish followed recognition. The older woman, mother of the younger, was bending over her husband when the daughter deliberately approached from behind, covered her mother’s eyes with her left hand and then cut the maternal throat with a keen knife she had in her right. Before any of the spectators could say or do a thing the girl threw off her bright plaid shawl, shook back her long hair, and with the bloody blade severed her own jugular. [2]

Following the campaign, Lieutenants Sickel and Rice worked diligently to ensure the recognition of their troopers for actions at Wounded Knee.  Their efforts paid off with five cavalrymen from E Troop receiving Medals of Honor–Sergeant A. W. McMillan, Sergeant W. G. Austin, Private M. Feaster, Private T. Sullivan, and Private H. Ziegner–and one with a Certificate of Merit–Sergeant J. F. Tritle.  The actions of both officers, however, received little thought until their gallantry was brought to the attention of Colonel Forsyth in the fall of 1891.  Writing on 8 October, Captain Henry J. Nowlan commander of I Troop, detailed his observations of Lieutenant Sickel at Wounded Knee.

Nowlan letter commending Sickel - 8 Oct 1891 page 1

(Click to enlarge) First page of Captain Nowlan’s letter detailing the gallant conduct of Lieutenant Sickel at the battle of Wounded Knee.

Sir: Having learned, incidentaly [sic], in conversation with other officers that certain gallant conduct on the part of 1st Lieut. H. G. Sickle [sic], 7th Cavalry in the battle of “Wounded Knee,” S. D., on Dec. 29th, 1890, had never been brought to your notice I consider it my duty and take pleasure in calling your attention to the following conduct which came under my personal observation.
Near the close of the fight, when the Indians in groups were making a stand in sheltered ravines, I, by your direction, carried an order to Lieut. Sickle. I found him in an isolated position with a few men of his Troop, hotly engaged with a party of Indians who had taken cover in a ravine. They could not be

Nowlan letter commending Sickel - 8 Oct 1891 page 2

(Click to enlarge) Second page of Captain Nowlan’s letter.

induced to surrender and had already killed two and wounded one of his small party.  At the time of my arrival he with his party had worked their way close up to the edge of the ravine and in doing so were necessarily exposed to a hot & close fire from the Indians.  The example set by Lieut. Sickle to his men upon this occasion and the courage and coolness he displayed earn my earnest admiration. Upon my return I was met by a scout who informed me that Captain Jackson’s Troop, which was in the bluffs back of Lt. Sickle’s position, but out of sight, was surrounded by hostile Indians from the Agency.  Realizing the danger Lt. Sickle & his small party would be in should this prove true & being still within hearing distance of him I warned him of the danger.  Yet, though he heard and understood me he still continued to hold his position and did so for some time afterwards.  His reason for remaining, as I learned later, was to protect the bodies of his dead soldiers, which

Nowlan letter commending Sickel - 8 Oct 1891 page 3

(Click to enlarge) Last page of Captain Nowlan’s letter.

he could not at that time recover, from mutilation by the Indians still in the ravine close to where the men had fallen.
Lieutenant Sickle’s conduct throughout this affair was deserving of all praise and would have been reported by me long ago had I not been under the impression, until within the last day or two, that it had already been brought to your notice.
Hoping it is not yet too late to do justice to a gallant young officer.
I have the honor to be
Very Respectfully
Your obdt. Servt.
H. J. Nowlan
Captain 7th Cavalry[3]

The regiment’s commander, Colonel James W. Forsyth, forwarded a letter of his own recommending that Lieutenants Sickel and Rice receive honorable mention and enclosed Captain Nowlan’s letter and a similar letter from Captain Varnum commending Lieutenant Rice’s gallantry at White Clay Creek.  Forsyth explained why the lieutenants’ commanding officer did not make the recommendations. “Tho’ both these officers belonged to Captain Ilsley’s Troop ‘E’, of the 7th Cavalry, he, Captain Ilsley, was in command of a Battalion and was not in a position to have any personal knowledge of the facts set forth in these communications.”  Forsyth went on to state, “I greatly regret that the information conveyed by them [Nowlan and Varnum] did not reach me soon enough to enable me to make these recommendations with the rest, but the failure to report the facts at the proper time was due, as will be seen from the reports, to a supposition, on the part of the officers stating them, that they had already been reported.”[4]

Based on Captain Nowlan and Captain Varnum’s letters and Colonel Forsyth’s subsequent recommendation for honorable mention for both Lieutenants, the conduct of those officers was a point of focus of Colonel Heyl’s investigation of acts of gallantry.  During that investigation in the later part of October, Lieutenant Sickel provided the following testimony.

Directly under my observation at Wounded Knee during the fight, December 29th, 1890, were Lieuts. Rice and Tompkins, 7th Cavalry.  Lieut. Tompkins had charge of a small party of enlisted men, on the other side of the ravine.  He was exposed by standing near the edge of the ravine.  I did not notice any specially conspicuous acts of gallantry on his part at that time.
I did not notice anything particularly conspicuous about Captain Capron’s actions at Wounded Knee.  My attention was directed to the ravine.  I did not notice any other officers.  I was separated from the rest, my field of action being near the pocket of the ravine.
Lieut. Rice, 7th Cavalry, remained with the gun when Lieut. Hawthorne was wounded, and then took charge of the gun and party.[5]

Several officers commented on the gallantry of Lieutenant Sickel that day. Lieutenant W. J. Nicholson, the 1st Battalion adjutant at Wounded Knee, stated, “I saw Lieutenants Sickel and Rice, 7th Cavalry, move their skirmish lines forward (at Wounded Knee), exposing themselves to a hot fire, when only thirty (30) yards from the Indians in the ravine.”  Lieutenant E. P. Brewer of G Troop testified, “I also saw Lieutenants Sickel and Rice, 7th Cavalry, who were dislodging some Indians.  All these officers were conspicuous in exposing themselves.”  Lieutenant S. R. H. Tompkins who was engaged on the other side of the ravine with a detachment of Captain Godfrey’s D Troop recalled, “While I was down at the ravine, Lieuts. Sickel and Rice came over from the village.  I consider the bearing of these officers gallant–Lieut. Rice particularly so.  Lieut. Sickel was on the skirmish line all the time.  These were the only officers who came under my observation during the hot fire.”[6]

Lieutenant S. Rice, second in command of E Troop during the fight, provided greater detail of his troop commander’s actions that day.

Lieut. Sickel was in command of Troop “E”, 7th Cavalry, to which I belonged, and immediately after the outbreak at Wounded Knee, our troop was ordered to clear out a ravine in which a party of Indians had taken a strong position in a pocket in the ravine.  I think we were engaged there about two hours.  Lieut. Sickel, while exercising command of his troop there, was conspicuously brave and gallant in my opinion, by exposing himself unnecessarily to the fire of the Indians and cheering and encouraging his men constantly….  Lieut. Sickel’s conduct throughout the whole engagement was particularly conspicuous.[7]

Colonel Heyl concluded his investigation stating, “In the case of Lieuts. Sickel and Rice, 7th Cavalry, the evidence seems to sustain the facts as represented for honorable mention.”[8]

Draft honorable mention 21 - Mann

(Click to enlarge). Draft of General Order No. 100 entry regarding Lieutenant Sickel.

Ultimately both lieutenants received honorable mention in General Order No. 100, but the details of Sickel’s actions that merited the commanding general’s accolades were watered down in the final draft approved by Major General Schofield. Like most citations from the Indian Wars era their was no detail of the actions which garnered laudatory praise.  The honorable mention stated only that Lieutenant Sickel was commended for “gallant service in action against hostile Sioux Indians at Wounded Knee Creek, S. D.”[9]

Born on 15 January 1854 in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, Horatio Gates Sickel, Jr., was the last of five children.  Despite having three older brothers, he was his father’s namesake.  The elder Horatio Gates Sickel was also a native Pennsylvanian born in 1817 in Bucks County. He was the son of John and Elizabeth (Vandergrift) Sickel.  As a young man Horatio apprenticed as a smith and worked in several trades including as a blacksmith, coach maker, and lamp maker. In 1841, he married Elizabeth VanSant, a twenty-year-old native of Bucks County.  Living in Quakertown, the young couple had two children there: Howard VanSant, born in 1843, and Ellen VanSant, the future Mrs. Augustus J. Miller, born in 1844.  The Sickels moved to Philadelphia where they had three more sons: Charles Albert born in 1848, William VanSant in 1851, and Horatio Gates, Jr., the subject of this post.  Horatio, Sr., also served for two decades as an officer in the volunteer militia such that when the Civil War broke out he was elected colonel of the Third Pennsylvania Volunteers. During his wartime service, he commanded his regiment and a brigade in combat and was rewarded for faithful and meritorious service with brevet promotions to brigadier general and major general.  Upon conclusion of the war he was appointed the Health Officer for the Port of Philadelphia. Horatio G. Sickel, Sr., died in April 1890, five years after the death of his wife and eight months before his namesake was called to action commanding a cavalry troop at Wounded Knee.[10]

Horatio G. Sickel, Jr., was appointed from the state of Pennsylvania to the United States Military Academy at West Point, New York, and began his cadetship in 1872.  He graduated on 14 June 1876 and stood thirty-sixth in a class of forty-seven men.  Sickel was appointed to the 14th Infantry Regiment the following day and began his graduation leave. The catastrophe that befell the 7th Cavalry ten days later on the Little Bighorn River had a dramatic impact on promotions and transfers across the Army in order to fill vacancies created by the loss of so many officers.  This effect was perhaps best described by General Ernest A. Garlington, a classmate of Sickel’s, who, writing in 1929, detailed the promotions and transfers associated with the 7th Cavalry that summer of 1876.

7th Cavalry Lieutenants - 1877 Army Register

(Click to enlarge) The roster of lieutenants in the 7th Cavalry Regiment listed in the 1877 Army Register shows the significant promotions and transfers that occurred following the Battle of the Little Bighorn.

On the 25th of June, 1876, Custer’s fight with the Sioux Indians on the Little Big Horn, Montana Territory occurred. On the 15th of June only one vacancy existed in the 7th Cavalry, to which the writer [Garlington] was assigned. The fatalities in the regiment promoted him [effective 25 June] and left twelve vacancies in the grade of second lieutenant. Certain second lieutenants were transferred from other Cavalry Regiments to these vacancies, but, through regimental esprit, and for other reasons, with three exceptions, these transfers were declined. Whereupon six members of the Class of 1876 were transferred (to date the 26th of June) to the Seventh Cavalry, namely, J. C. Gresham, H. L. Scott, L. S. McCormick, A. J. Russell, H. G. Sickel, and H. J. Slocum, carrying with them the strong bond of friend and comrade established during cadet days which continued unbroken through the many years of intimate association under the old system of regimental promotion.[11]

Sickel served with the 7th Cavalry for twenty-seven years, the first twelve at various posts in the Dakota Territory where he participated in several campaigns and scouting expeditions, escorted prisoners, and commanded a troop of Indian Scouts.[12]

While stationed at Fort Meade, the thirty-one-year-old cavalry officer took leave in the summer of 1885 and married Miss Mary Louise Jouett in New Orleans, Louisiana, on 5 June. The twenty-two-year-old native of St Louis was the only child of William Robards Jouett, Jr., and Anne F. Schaumburg.  She was orphaned at the age of four when her parents died in 1865, her father in late February and her mother in early April.  Mary accompanied her husband back to the Dakota Territory where she gave birth to a daughter, Anna.  The child died in infancy and was initially buried at Fort Yates in March 1888.  Two months later the Sickels removed their daughter’s body and had her laid to rest in the Bellefontaine Cemetery, St Louis, in the same plot where Mary’s parent’s and maternal grandparents were buried.[13]

Lieutenant Sickel was stationed with the portion of the regiment at Fort Sill, Oklahoma Territory, in 1888 and two years later at Fort Riley just prior to the commencement of the Pine Ridge Campaign of November 1890 – January 1891.  While stationed at Fort Sill the Sickels had a second child, Howard Wright, born in January 1890.  The child died of lung and heart disease nine months later about the time that E Troop was relocating to Fort Riley.  Mary apparently remained at Fort Sill until after the campaign when Lieutenant Sickel was able to again take leave. They buried their second infant child in February 1891 next to their daughter and Mary’s parents.  Horatio and Mary Sickel had no more children.[14]

Twice he was detached from the regiment for recruiting duty at Jefferson Barracks, Missouri.  Sickel served as the regimental adjutant for eighteen months until his promotion to captain in May 1896, and saw duty with the 7th in Arizona at Forts Grant and Huachuca.  During the Spanish-American War, the regiment remained on border duty in Arizona, but soon after was moved to Huntsville, Alabama, then Macon, Georgia before taking up occupation duty at Camp Columbia in Havana, Cuba.[15]

Sickel was promoted to major and transferred to the newly formed 12th Cavalry Regiment in 1903 and served his remaining thirteen years in uniform with that regiment.  His duties took him to the Philippine Islands where he commanded the military station at Calamba, Laguna, and later the Santa Mesa Garrison at Manila.  Returning to the United States, he was posted at Fort Oglethorpe, Georgia, Fort Slocum, New York, and Boston, Massachusetts.  Sickel returned to the Philippines in 1909 serving eighteen months at Fort William McKinley.  He returned to Fort Huachuca where he was promoted in 1911 to lieutenant colonel and commanded a squadron of the 12th Cavalry.  Sickel was promoted a colonel of cavalry in 1912 and commanded Fort Robinson, Nebraska, before taking command of the 12th Cavalry Regiment at Columbus, New Mexico, in 1914.  He served his final years at the head of that regiment during the turbulent Mexican Border period that was highlighted by General Pershing’s Punitive Expedition.[16]

Col. Sickel Kills Self at St. Louis - The Oregon Daily Journal 19180909

The Oregon Daily Journal was one of many newspapers across the country that carried the news of Colonel Sickel’s suicide.

Colonel Sickel was retired by law on his sixty-fourth birthday in January 1918, and although many of his peers returned to service at garrisons in the United States during World War I, Sickel retired with his wife, Mary, to their home in St Louis, Missouri. Colonel Sickel lost all of his siblings in the few short years before his retirement.  His oldest brother, Howard, died in 1912, Charles and William in 1914, and his sister, Mrs. Ellen Miller, in 1915.  Perhaps their recent deaths coupled with his failing health led him to desperation, for on 9 September 1918, the retired Army colonel with almost forty-two years of service took his own life when he shot himself in his upstairs bedroom.[17]

Col Horatio Gates Sickel

Photograph of Colonel Horatio Gates Sickel, Jr., circa 1914. His uniform is adorned with the Indian Wars Campaign Medal and the Military Order of the Loyal Legion of the United States hereditary medal.

In a 1919 obituary for the West Point Association of Graduates, a fellow classmate recalled of Colonel Sickel:

By his classmates he is remembered always as “Tiny” Sickel.  The name seemed naturally to belong to him from his earliest days at the Academy, and was used more as a term of endearment than as nickname, in unconscious recognition of the universal affection of his classmates; an affection that increased and ripened until graduation scattered the members throughout the service, and which the separation of after years did not weaken.  The later association of the writer with “Tiny,” although long deferred because of difference of service, was particularly delightful.  Our first meeting after graduation was in 1903, in St. Louis, at the dedication of the World’s Fair Grounds.  It was so short that there was scarcely time for us to recognize each other, after the lapse of twenty-seven years, but it served as a new starting point toward better acquaintance at our next meeting.  A few years later found us serving together at Fort William McKinley, P. I., and still later when we were both approaching the retiring age, there were numerous delightful meetings while service together in the Islands, and the later meetings broadened and strengthened our friendship.  I learned to know his modest, generous nature that led him always to consider others before himself; to know the high ideals that regulated his daily life and the nobility of his character as a man.[18]

Colonel Horatio Gates Sickel, Jr., was buried in the Bellefontaine Cemetery in St Louis adjacent to his infant children, Anna and Howard, and his wife’s parents, grandparents and great-grandparents.  Mary Sickel survived her husband by more than a decade.  She passed away on 13 August 1930 and was laid to rest by her husband’s side in a plot surrounded by family.[19]

Colonel Horatio Gates Sickel, Jr., and his wife, Mary Louise, nee Jouett, are buried in the Bellefontaine Cemetery at St Louis, Missouri.[20]


[1] Adjutant General’s Officer, “7th Cavalry, Troop E, Jan. 1885 – Dec. 1897,” Muster Rolls of Regular Army Organizations, 1784 –  Oct. 31, 1912, Record Group 94, (Washington: National Archives Record Administration).
[2] “At Wounded Knee; Incidents and Happenings in the Terrible Fight,” The Times (Philadelphia: 9 Feb 1891), 3.
[3] Adjutant General’s Office, Honorable Mention file for Horatio G. Sickel, Principal Record Division, file 3466, Record Group: 94, Stack area: 8W3, Row: 7, Compartment 30, Shelf: 2. Research conducted by Vonnie S. Zullo of The Horse Soldier Research Service.
[4] Ibid.
[5] Ibid.
[6] Ibid.
[7] Ibid.
[8] Ibid.
[9] Ibid.
[10] Samuel P. Bates, Martial Deeds of Pennsylvania (Philadelphia: T. H. Davis & Co., 1875), 844–847; John P. Nicholson, recorder, Register of the Commandery of the State of Pennsylvania from April 15 1865 to May 5 1887 (Philadelphia: Military Order of the Loyal Legion of the United States, 1887), 4;, United States Federal Census (Provo, UT, USA: Operations, Inc., 2009), Year: 1860, Census Place: Philadelphia Ward 14 Division 1, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, Roll: M653_1164, Page: 157, Image: 161, Family History Library Film: 805164; Year: 1870, Census Place: Philadelphia Ward 14 Dist 41 (2nd Enum), Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, Roll:M593_1426, Page: 441A, Image: 367, Family History Library Film: 552925.
[11] Association of Graduates, Sixtieth Annual Reunion of the Association of the Graduates of the United States Military Academy, June 12, 1929 (West Point: Association of Graduates, 1929), 231.  Herbert J. Slocum was a member of the West Point class of 1876, but was dismissed from the academy for academic deficiency during his final year.  He received a direct appointment from the state of Illinois on 21 June, just a week after his former classmates had graduated and received their commissions.  Originally appointed to the 25th Infantry Regiment, his date of transfer to the 7th Cavalry was 28 June 1876.
[12] George W. Collum, Biographical Register of the Officers and Graduates of the United States Military Academy at West Point, New York, since its establishment in 1802, vol. 3 (Boston: Houghton, Mifflin & Co., 1891), 266.
[13] Hunting For Bears, comp., Missouri Marriages, 1766-1983 (Provo, UT, USA: Operations Inc, 2004); St. Louis Genealogical Society, comp., St. Louis City Death Records, 1850-1902 (Provo, UT, USA: Operations Inc, 2001), Volume: L, Page: 55, County Library: RDSL 8, Missouri Archive: C 10366, SLGS Rolls: 307;, New Orleans, Louisiana, Marriage Records Index, 1831-1920 (Provo, UT, USA: Operations Inc, 2004);, U.S. Military Burial Registers, 1768-1921 ( Provo, UT, USA: Operations Inc, 2007), State: Dakota Territory, Page#: 135; Bellafontaine Cemetery Association, (, accessed 9 Aug 2015.
[14] Collum, Biographical Register, vol. 3, 266; Bellafontaine Cemetery Association, (, accessed 9 Aug 2015.
[15] Collum, Biographical Register, vol. 4, 272; Collum, Biographical Register, vol. 5, 248.
[16] Ibid., Collum, Biographical Register, vol. 6, 220
[17] Ibid., 220 – 221; “Col. Sickel Kills Self at St. Louis,” The Oregon Daily Journal (9 Sep 1918); “Col. Sickle Ends His Life,” El Paso Herald (10 Sep 1918).
[18] Association of Graduates, Sixtieth Annual Reunion of the Association of the Graduates of the United States Military Academy, June 12, 1929 (West Point: Association of Graduates, 1929), 231.
[19] Bellafontaine Cemetery Association, (, accessed 9 Aug 2015.
[20] Connie Nisinger, photo., “Horatio Gates Sickel,” FindAGrave ( posted 8 Mar 2013, accessed 14 Jun 2015.

Citation for this article: Samuel L. Russell, “First Lieutenant Horatio Gates Sickel, Commander, E Troop, 7th Cavalry,” Army at Wounded Knee ( posted 9 Aug 2015, accessed date __________.

Posted in Officers | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | 5 Comments